Guides

Open vs Closed Captions: What's the Difference?

By the Capiyo team ·

Short answer: Open captions are part of the picture, so everyone sees them and you control the look. Closed captions are a separate text track that the viewer switches on, so they can be hidden but cannot be styled by you. For short vertical videos, open captions are the usual choice; for long YouTube videos, add closed captions too.

The difference in one line each

  • Open captions are burned into the video. They are part of the picture and cannot be turned off.
  • Closed captions are a separate text track. The viewer turns them on or off, usually with a CC button.

The W3C’s Web Accessibility Initiative describes it the same way: most captions are closed, and open captions “are always displayed and cannot be turned off” (W3C WAI, Captions/Subtitles).

Side by side

Open captions Closed captions
Where the text lives In the video picture In a separate file or track
Can the viewer hide them? No Yes
Can you style them? Fully: font, colour, size, animation, position Barely: the player decides the look
Survive download and repost? Yes, always Only if the platform keeps the track
Readable as text by the platform No Yes
Best for Reels, Shorts, social clips, ads Long YouTube videos, courses, films

Who captions help

Captions exist first for people who are Deaf or hard of hearing. The same W3C page notes they also help people who cannot hear the audio at that moment, and people who take in written words more easily than speech. On social video that covers a lot of viewers: someone on a bus, someone in a quiet office, someone whose first language is not the one you speak.

Which one should you use?

For Reels, Shorts and other short vertical video: open captions. They show for every viewer without any setting, they can match your brand and mood, and they stay when the video is shared to WhatsApp or posted on another app.

For long YouTube videos: closed captions, and open ones if you like. A closed track lets viewers choose, can be translated by the player, and gives YouTube text to work with.

For both at once: burn open captions into short clips, and upload a caption file for long uploads.

Making open captions

Open captions need a tool that writes the words, times them, and draws them onto the video. Capiyo does that for videos up to 4 minutes: it writes every word, animates it in one of 67 styles, and gives you back a 1080p MP4 with the captions burned in. Your first 180 seconds are free.

Questions

Are subtitles the same as captions?

People often use the words for the same thing. Strictly, captions include sounds that matter, like laughter or music, for viewers who cannot hear. Subtitles are often just the dialogue, sometimes translated into another language.

Can I have both open and closed captions on one video?

Yes. Burn styled captions into the video for everyone, and upload a caption file to YouTube as well. Viewers who turn on CC will see both, so many creators only add a closed track to long videos.

Can search engines read open captions?

Open captions are part of the image, so a platform cannot read them as text the way it reads a caption file. If text matters for search, also write a good title and description, and add a caption file where the platform allows it.

Your next video deserves better captions.

180 seconds free. Then ₹29 for 900 seconds. No subscription.